HMSA announced earlier in 2026 that it was shifting away from managed care contracting and moving to a fee-for-service payment model, then delayed the transition until January 1, 2027, citing the need for more preparation time. The June 8, 2026 delay announcement came after physician groups and Governor Josh Green raised concerns about whether providers were ready for the operational change.
HMSA covers roughly 750,000 Hawaii residents, more than half the state's population. The shift matters at scale. Under the existing managed care framework, physician groups receive bundled payments designed to incentivize coordinated care. Under fee-for-service, providers get paid individually for each service rendered. That's a familiar model nationally, but it represents a significant operational change for practice groups that have built their workflows and staffing models around managed care payments.
Governor Green engaged publicly with HMSA leadership on the transition, particularly around the impact on Neighbor Island providers. HMSA's rate proposals for Neighbor Island practices included increases of approximately 15 percent under the new model, but critics argued the administrative burden of transitioning to fee-for-service billing could offset any rate improvement for small clinics. Oahu-based groups generally have more administrative infrastructure to absorb the change than rural practices on Maui, Hawaii Island, or Kauai.
Hawaii's physician workforce is already thin relative to population, with significant shortages in primary care and specialty medicine on the Neighbor Islands. Healthcare advocates worry a disruptive payment model transition could push physicians to leave the HMSA network entirely, reducing access for the insurer's members at a time when the state is already grappling with provider availability outside Honolulu.
HMSA has not released a full implementation plan for the January 2027 launch. Physician groups have been told to prepare while the state monitors the rollout.
